Here is a fun and obsessive blog post about regional variation in different Spanish translations of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (or Sorcerer’s Stone in the American version).
The author, “Urbanabydos”, analyzes 24 different Spanish editions of the book, dividing them on linguistic grounds into European, Southern Cone (Argentina +), and other Latin American.
Differences in subject pronoun usage are an obvious feature to look for. Surprisingly, Urbanabydos doesn’t mention voseo. However, for ustedes (Europe) versus vosotros (Latin America, including Southern Cone), (s)he gives the example of Harry’s reaction when he finds out his aunt and uncle already knew about Hogwarts: ¿Ustedes sabían? versus ¿Vosotros lo sabíais?
Besides ustedes/vosotros, the author identifies four phrases with consistent regional treatments:
In later editions, “tawny owl” changed to búho pardo in the Southern Cone and Europe editions. Urbanabydos’s post analyzes the difference between lechuza and búho and why the word choice may have evolved over time.
My favorite part of the post explains that early editions translated ‘The mirror of Erised’ as El espejo de Erised, but that as editors (and the general public) figured out that Erised was Desire read backwards, this changed to El espejo de Oesed (Deseo backwards).
A must-read for fans of both Spanish and Harry Potter!
Why are there 24 editions. Wouldn’t one suffice?
When Harry Potter came to the U.S., some of the more British aspects of the book’s English were Americanized. Likewise one would expect to find differences among the various Spanish-language editions. The author of this article also found chronological differences, i.e. changes between earlier and later editions. The change from Erised to Oesed is a perfect example — but you might not understand it if you haven’t read the book.
Spanish is spoken in more than 20 countries. Some regional differences in speech and culture warrant different editions. Then there’s different editions for different formats: paperback, hardcover, etc.
I’m sure there is not just one edition for the English language either.
I’d be a lot cooler if each translation/version had a corresponding isbn or was more clearly labeled
That’s a reasonable idea. You can probably contact the author via their blog.
Hi! I’m looking for the ISBN of the Harry Poter books translated to Spanish (preferably using Spanish from Latin America an not Spain)
¿Surely you can find this information on Amazon?
Same! Looking specifically for the hardcover editions of Harry Potter in Latin American Spanish. I can’t find it online, but I know they’re there! Does anyone know the ISBN numbers of where I can buy them?
Thanks in advance!